After hearing the dire warnings of deflation that have become
the standard talking points of most economists, American
investors may be reaching for a bottle of Prozac. I believe that
their anxiety is misplaced. Unfortunately, modern economists
don't understand what deflation is or why, in reality, we have
much more to fear from inflation.
Moderate deflation is actually the natural trend of a productive
economy. If a producer can increase his output per unit of
input, then he can afford to expand his market by lowering
prices while still increasing profits. In that way, deflation
allows consumers to buy items that they may not have previously
afforded. It also promotes savings, which is essential for
investment and capital development. (For a simple description of
this process, read Chapter 5 of Peter's new book,
How an Economy Grows and Why it Crashes)
Deflation is also the normal consequence of a contracting
economy. In a recession, there is a reduction in the amount of
goods and services available for consumption. In order to keep
prices from rising (due to shrinking supply), the central bank
should allow the money supply to fall in line with the reduction
in output. Also, during an economic contraction, consumers put
downward pressure on prices by responsibly selling assets to pay
down debt.
Many economists mistakenly claim that the Great Depression of
the 1930s was caused by a 30% contraction in the money supply.
The truth is that all depressions are caused by the reversal of
a massive credit expansion. The reduction in money supply is
part of a healing process that brings the overall level of
prices back to a sustainable condition.
Looking at today's situation, just because we have a few months
of sequential declines in CPI and PPI doesn't mean that
deflation has become a secular trend. Year-over-year (YOY)
growth in the M2 money supply is 2%; therefore, since the money
supply is still growing, we are experiencing inflation rather
than deflation.
Considering that evidence of inflation abounds, the Federal
Reserve has pulled off a good trick by convincing Americans that
we are about to "suffer" through a protracted period of
deflation. Why have we been so easily duped? In the past ten
years, the monetary base has grown from $600 billion to $2
trillion. This expansion has accompanied a rise in the price of
gold from below $300/oz at the beginning of the decade to around
$1,200/oz today. The price of gold is the best arbiter for a
currency's purchasing power. Therefore, gold is still telling us
that inflation is eroding the value of our dollar.
Other commodities, like crude oil, are telling the same story.
Ten years ago, a barrel of oil was trading for $25. Today, it is
$78.
Since 2001, the US dollar has lost over 30% of its value against
our largest trading partners and more than 7% of its value since
June alone. These facts are causing the mainstream economists to
wring their hands about deflation?
More recently, YOY increases in the CPI, PPI, and import prices
were 1.1%, 2.7%, and 4.5% respectively. Even though these YOY
increases aren't evidence of runaway inflation, they still can't
be construed as deflation.
The truth is consumers should be allowed the advantages of
falling prices. Aggregate hours worked are down 8% since their
peak in March of 2008. Since the money supply should fall along
with the decline of the number of people in the work force,
price levels should be falling too. But that is not what we see
today.
If the monetary base continues to stagnate and banks stop
lending to the government through Treasury purchases, we could
see a deflationary environment sometime in the future. But given
the current policy drift, that scenario appears unlikely.
Even if deflation were to take hold, it would not be something
to fear. Lower prices are beneficial for those who have been
thrown out of work, and falling prices allow asset values to
reach a level that can be sustained by the free market. The fact
is that prices should currently be falling in order to reconcile
the imbalances brought about by decades of profligate spending
and borrowing. Deflation... I say bring it on!
But that is not what is occurring today. Because of the towering
level of US sovereign debt, it is inflation that remains the
clear and present danger.
The national debt now stands at $13.24 trillion - nearly 92% of
the entire output of goods and services in the US economy this
year. In its mid-session review, the OMB revised its 2011
federal budget deficit projection to $1.42 trillion, down only
slightly from the $1.47 trillion estimate for this year's
deficit. Given this intractable and unsustainable level of
obligations, the last thing the Fed and Administration can
tolerate is to increase the burden of that debt by allowing the
money supply to shrink.
A reduction in the supply of money (deflation) would cause the
cost of debt to rise. An increase in the purchasing power of
money also means it is more difficult to acquire the new money
needed to reduce debt levels. Conversely, increasing the supply
of money (inflation) reduces the cost of debt. With these
incentives firmly entrenched, the last thing Americans will have
to "worry" about is deflation.
Given the obvious mathematics, one wonders why Treasury yields
remain at historic lows. The bond vigilantes are indeed in a
coma. However, despite the mountain of complacency that their
slumber has inspired, this golden age of E-Z financing can't
last forever.